Elizabeth Taylor Believed Her First Oscar Was a 'Sympathy' Award After Near-Death Surgery
Hollywood icon Elizabeth Taylor, renowned for her beauty, talent, and tumultuous life, harboured a surprising belief about her first Academy Award. Despite receiving the Best Actress Oscar in 1961 for her role in Butterfield 8, Taylor privately felt the win was largely due to 'sympathy' following a harrowing surgery where she reportedly 'died four times'.
The revelation, shared in an authorized biography, paints a fascinating picture of a star grappling with the complexities of fame and recognition. Taylor’s comments highlight a vulnerability rarely seen behind the glamorous facade she presented to the world. The surgery in question was a particularly difficult one, leaving Taylor in a precarious condition and prompting the dramatic claims about her repeated brushes with death.
Butterfield 8, a film often viewed as less prestigious than some of her other roles, presented a challenging character for Taylor. She portrayed Gloria Wandrous, a struggling model with a complex relationship with a married man. The film sparked controversy and criticism, with some critics questioning Taylor’s performance. Despite this, her portrayal was deemed worthy of the Oscar, marking a significant milestone in her career.
However, Taylor's own assessment of the win suggests a degree of ambivalence. She reportedly confided in friends and those close to her that she felt the Academy had been swayed by her recent ordeal. This perspective reveals a sharp, self-aware mind beneath the celebrity persona – a woman who understood the power of public perception and the potential for it to influence even the most prestigious awards.
This anecdote adds another layer to the already rich and complex story of Elizabeth Taylor. It’s a reminder that even the most celebrated figures can experience doubt and insecurity, and that the pursuit of recognition is often intertwined with personal struggles. It underscores the human element behind the dazzling lights of Hollywood, revealing a woman who, despite her extraordinary life, remained grounded in a certain sense of realism and self-assessment.
Taylor’s career spanned decades, and she would go on to win a second Oscar for Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, a performance widely considered to be one of her finest. However, the lingering question of her initial Oscar win remains a captivating glimpse into the mind of a true legend.
The story serves as a poignant testament to Elizabeth Taylor’s enduring legacy, not just as a captivating actress but as a woman who, even in the face of overwhelming fame, retained a remarkable sense of self-awareness and honesty.