Saints' De Koning Chase: Should St Kilda Focus on Their Own Stars First?
The AFL trade period is heating up, and St Kilda are reportedly throwing serious money – a reported $1.7 million per season – at Tom De Koning. But is this the right move for the Saints? In this week's Early Tackle, Scott Gullan argues that St Kilda's priority should be securing the future of two key players already within their ranks: a dynamic duo whose chemistry and connection are vital to the club's aspirations.
The pursuit of De Koning, a talented ruckman from Collingwood, certainly makes sense on paper. He offers a potential upgrade and addresses a need. However, Gullan contends that focusing resources on retaining and rewarding existing talent – specifically these two close-knit teammates – represents a smarter, more sustainable strategy.
Why Prioritise Existing Talent?
There's a significant advantage to building a team around players who already understand the club's culture, systems, and have established relationships on and off the field. These two mates have demonstrably built a strong connection, evident in their on-field synergy and understanding. Injecting a new player, regardless of their talent, takes time to integrate and reach that same level of cohesion.
Furthermore, chasing high-profile targets like De Koning often comes with inflated price tags and increased pressure. Securing existing players, on the other hand, can be a more cost-effective and less disruptive approach. It sends a powerful message to the entire playing list: that the club values loyalty and commitment.
The De Koning Question Remains
That’s not to say De Koning isn’t a quality player. He undoubtedly is. However, St Kilda needs to carefully weigh the potential benefits against the cost and the impact on its existing roster. The Saints need to consider if the investment in De Koning will truly move the needle, or if they'd be better served strengthening their current foundations. A bidding war for De Koning could significantly deplete their salary cap, leaving them with less flexibility to address other needs.
Looking Ahead for St Kilda
The Saints face a crucial period. Their performance in the next few weeks, both on and off the field, will shape their trajectory for seasons to come. Securing the futures of their key players, including these two mates, is paramount. While the allure of a player like De Koning is understandable, St Kilda needs to remember the importance of nurturing what they already have. It’s time to look after their own backyard before venturing too far afield.
Catch the full Early Tackle for more insights and analysis on all the AFL news and storylines.
